The arguments for the uses of the ebonics in the united states

When citing an essay from our library, you can use "Kibin" as the author.

How to speak ebonics

I know of at least four Op-Ed submissions which they summarily rejected by Salikoko Mufwene, by Geoffrey Pullum, by Gene Searchinger, and myself , and there were undoubedtedly others. This evidence was of three kinds: 1 Piestrup's study in Oakland itself which showed that teachers who constantly interrupted Ebonics-speaking children to correct them produced the lowest-scoring and most apathetic readers, while teachers who built artfully on the children's language produced the highest-scoring and most enthusiastic readers; 2 Evidence from the Bidialectal program in 5th and 6th grades in DeKalb county, Georgia and at Aurora University outside Chicago that Contrastive Analysis similar to that employed in the SEP and in Oakland yields greater progress in reading and writing for Ebonics speakers than conventional methods; 3 Evidence that teaching children to read first in their vernacular, and then transitioning to the standard variety, has led to better reading results, both among African American students Simpkins and Simpkins , and in Europe. There isn't a public personage of stature in the land, white or black, left or right, Democrat or Republican, who doesn't say that the Oakland, Calif. English used by African Americans ranges from the distinctive styles of master orators like Martin Luther King and Jesse Jackson, through urban and rural vernaculars influenced by Southern roots this is what is most commonly called AAVE , to the language of recent immigrants from the Caribbean, Africa and elsewhere, to Standard and local Englishes identical to those used by members of other communities. In the case at hand, the mainstream view was that Ebonics itself was street slang, and that Oakland teachers were going to teach in it, or allow students to talk or write in it instead of in English. However, in harboring this frustration, we seem to have forgotten what advertisers of Colgate toothpaste and other products never forget: that the message has to be repeated over and over, anew for each generation and each different audience type, and preferably in simple, direct and arresting language which the public can understand and appreciate. Further reading Baugh, John. The essays in our library are intended to serve as content examples to inspire you as you write your own essay. Geoffrey Pullum also wrote a good general interest piece on Ebonics in the April issue of Nature magazine. Language in the inner city: Studies in the Black English Vernacular. Manufacturing consent : the political economy of the mass media. I have no problem with taking Black English into account in schools. In order to teach them standard English, the board has rightfully concluded that teachers need to understand and be able to teach children the differences between these two linguistic varieties. Overview[ edit ] By definition, as a vernacular dialect of English, AAVE has never received the social prestige of a standard dialect , leading to widespread and long-standing misconceptions that it is a grammatically inferior form of English, which linguistics research of the twentieth century has soundly refuted. The Oakland Board is trying to promulgate a new set of political ideas about AAE as a legitimate form of speech, partly for the sake of African-American pride, but mainly for the sake of teaching standard English in an emotionally positive way.

Mary Hoover, the longtime AAVE and Education specialist from Howard University, was working in the Oakland School District at the time, and she arranged for Carolyn Getridge, the Superintendent of the Oakland School Board, to contact me for linguistic references and information which she could use in dealing with a sceptical if not hostile press.

However, Senator Arlen Specter seemed to be impressed with the testimony.

How to speak black american english

In order to teach them standard English, the board has rightfully concluded that teachers need to understand and be able to teach children the differences between these two linguistic varieties. Black English has also been one of the major contributors of vocabulary to American English in general. In the heat of that politicized moment, linguists attempted not only to redefine Ebonics, but also to illustrate some of the problems that can arise when one considers how languages in different parts of the world are actually defined. For instance, in the California Assessment Program, third grade kids in the primarily white, middle class Palo Alto School District scored on the 94th percentile in writing; by the third grade, they had topped out at the 99 percentile. There isn't a public personage of stature in the land, white or black, left or right, Democrat or Republican, who doesn't say that the Oakland, Calif. Imagine the budgetary impact of expanding bilingual education programs to include African Americans; clearly, neither educators nor politicians had ever pondered or planned for such a prospect. Eventually, my revised article was accepted, appearing in the December issue. The English history of African American English. After that, I continued to get occasional overtures from the media, but my main involvement since then has been responding to requests from conference organizers, universities, church and community groups to talk about the Ebonics controversy or participate in panel discussions on the topic, replying to email and other requests for information from high school and college students doing papers on Ebonics, and trying to expand my own reading, research and writing on the subject. The Oakland School Board did not expect the hostility that followed their ill-advised linguistic assertion that Ebonics was the authentic language of their African-American students. Thinking about this, however, it occurred to me -- there already ARE books on Black English, at least, long readily available in paperback such as Dillard and Smitherman The resolution set off a firestorm of media criticism and ignited a national debate. An example would be the use of the verb "come" to express the speaker's indignation about an action, "He come walkin' in here like he owned the damn place. Herman, Edward, and Noam Chomsky.

Some emphasize its English origins, pointing to the fact that most of the vocabulary of Ebonics is from English and that much of its pronunciation e.

Likening the ebonics debate to the O. Some Ebonics pronunciations are more unique, for instance, dropping b, d, or g at the beginning of auxiliary verbs like 'don't' and 'gonna', yielding Ah 'on know for "I don't know" and ama do it for "I'm going to do it.

Several other linguists who could not be present including myself submitted letters to be read into the Senate record.

black english vs standard english

And so, we still do not have one single definition of Ebonics. Some deny its existence like the black Chicagoan whose words "Ain't nobody here talkin' no Ebonics" belied his claim. Although I labored long and hard at it, my first submission was rejected by the editor, who said that it was too technical.

The educational failure of African American children can, at best, be only partially addressed through teacher training on AAE. Marcyliena Morgan, Linguistic Anthropology, UCLA After sitting through a string of tasteless jokes about the Oakland School District's approval of a language education policy for African American students, I now realize that linguists and educators have failed to inform Americans about varieties of English used throughout the country and the link between these dialects and culture, social class, geographic region and identity.

You know how looking at a math problem similar to the one you're stuck on can help you get unstuck? Rickfordhowever, argues that since both White and Black dialects have some consonant cluster reduction, that the real difference lies not in the presence or absence of consonant cluster reduction but in the different weightings of phonological sound-oriented and grammatical constraints.

Rated 5/10 based on 44 review
Views of linguists and anthropologists on the Ebonics issue (Part 1)