Is euthanasia morally and philosophically justifiable essay

is euthanasia justified

De Vries and J. Essay - The morality of active euthanasia and whether or not it should be legalized is quite a controversial topic within the medical field that has long been debated by many philosophers. The danger of violating the right to life is so great that we should ban euthanasia even if it means violating the right to die.

euthanasia essay introduction

On the one hand, premise 5 is setting down certain conditions for moral rightness. Spreeuwenberg, and L.

Is euthanasia morally and philosophically justifiable essay

How so? Others will object because they believe that such a proposal is wide-open to abuse, and would ultimately lead to involuntary euthanasia because of shortage of health resources. There are different ways of understanding this distinction. Such a definition is, as Tooley notes, narrower than his in at least three ways. Secular philosophers put forward a number of technical arguments, mostly based on the duty to preserve life because it has value in itself, or the importance of regarding all human beings as ends rather than means. People who oppose euthanasia still believe it's inherently wrong — it can't be morally justified and even compassionate motives don't make it ethically acceptable. It is these twin values that should guide medical care, not the preservation of life at all costs, or the preservation of life without regard to whether patients want their lives prolonged should they judge that life is no longer of benefit or value to them. This is possible: some people might wrongfully break potentially good rules. Even the Catholic Church in recent times has been prepared to agree that it is permissible, in a case like this, to turn off the respirator. Passive Euthanasia generally refers to the ending of a persons life by removing the person from a life-sustaining machine, such as a respirator She plans to drown him in the bathtub and make it look like an accident. Indeed, in a recent wide-ranging study of attitudes and practices of voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide covering two continents, a prominent critic of these practices has concluded in agreement with his co-authors that little evidence exists of abuse, particularly of the vulnerable see Emanuel, et al. Woodward, P.

Recently, some pro-euthanasia advocates have gone further, arguing that respect for people's rights to autonomy and self-determination means competent adults have a right to die at a time of their choosing, and the state has no right to prevent them from doing so.

Those who consider that cases like these show the first condition to be too restrictive e.

euthanasia speech

Why, for example, should those suffering from depression, or forms of dementia, not be eligible for medically assisted dying? As previously mentioned, a major source of distress for many dying patients is the frustration that comes with being unable to satisfy their autonomous wishes.

Rated 7/10 based on 93 review
When is euthanasia justified?