Critical review essay of guns germs and steel

Writing, independently developed by the Aztecs and previous Mesoamerican civilisations, never reached the Incas. With the help of pack animals farming in Europe became more widespread than elsewhere. The underlying vision of humanity as a salad-bowl made up of distinct and insoluble ethnic identities would provide a clue, and the stress on the arrival of Old World technologies and pathogens in the New World as the archetypal event of human diffusion and coalescence would confirm this.

A book seeking to answer such questions would have to add a fourth totem of Western progress to its title and be called, perhaps, Guns, Germs, Steel and Coca-Cola.

Guns germs and steel main argument

As a result of this there population swelled to 00, Hedevelopedapassionforornithology—thestudyofbirds—and began visiting the South Paciic island of New Guinea regularly. Contrast this with the minimal topographical fragmentation of China combined with its relative isolation from other Eurasian civilisations , and the much greater isolation of different regions of the Americas, the former promoting early growth followed by stagnation, the latter inhibiting communication and innovation. Where plants and animals could easily be domesticated, as in the Fertile Crescent of the Middle East, settled agriculture emerged first, and was then diffused to other suitable areas. By AD, most of China was politically united. His hypothesis was very original and at first looked very simple, it was guns, germs and steel. A g the comparative method aims to look at similar casesthatproduceddiferentoutcomesanddiferentcasesthatproduced similar outcomes. Europe's moderate level of topographical fragmentation meant its peoples were isolated enough to remain political rivals, but not isolated enough for ideas to spread in this competitive milieu. Writing, independently developed by the Aztecs and previous Mesoamerican civilisations, never reached the Incas. The Maori and Mirror lived on islands relatively close to one another. Even more compressed is the account of socio-political institutions on which many other analyses of the modern world depend. They also suggest irresistible comparisons with events nearer home. Around the time human history started, 50, years ago. The Maori could easily field a larger, better armed, and better trained force compared to the Mirror who had all but renounced warfare altogether.

There are a number of difficulties here. In the 13th century, Chinese ships of exploration reached the coast of East Africa.

Guns germs and steel introduction

The domestication of animals also gave the Europeans an advantage over the Native Americans. Eurasian crops never made it across the desert and the jungle to temperate Southern Africa till the Dutch brought them there in ocean-going ships. With the help of advanced steel weapons and armor, and horses and cavalry the Incas were easily defeated. In your essay, you will work with a partner. Diffusion is the key concept here - some continents and regions were more favourable than others, because of internal or external connections. The dockyards were closed, and there were no nearby rivals to the Chinese Empire to expose the folly of this abandonment of new technology. In the 13th century, Chinese ships of exploration reached the coast of East Africa. When people give up hunting and gathering in favor of agriculture, heargues,theyarenolongerfocusedonsubsistence—thatis,meeting theneedsoftheirimmediatesurvival—byfollowingresourcessuchas seasonalrainandmigratinganimals. Maybe there is a third explanation. So it is not surprising that when he looks at more recent history, say of the last few hundred years, he starts getting on to some shaky ground. The reason that the East to Westward axis is important is because it allows the already domesticated plant species to easily travel 1 ,OHO mile and till be viable. Andthearrangement of Eurasia itself along an east—west axis, as opposed to a north—south axis, makes the exchange of plants and ideas in this region easier.

He believes that in the. While this may not seem important, it played a critical role in the Europeans colonization of the Americas and Africa. In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Diamond applies his previous training to the analysis of human societies. He suggested that some societies and cultures had advantages due to their geography The son raised his ax and rushed at the murderer but was wrestled to the ground by friends; then the murderer came to the prostrate son with an ax and was also wrestled down.

Historians cannot allow scientists to tell them how to do their job; if they did, then history would vanish for ever into the intellectual establishment of rational positivism, and would lose its capacity - to which Professor Diamond is sensitive - to unite beliefs about the present with an understanding of the past in ways that can influence the future.

guns germs and steel documentary

The spread of technology, and of the military conquests and economic changes that it has wrought over the past thousand years, is dismissed as largely a question of historical accident.

In fact, the Aztecs only used wheels for toys.

Guns germs and steel summary

It can be used in nearlyeverydisciplinethatlooksatcauses. In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Diamond applies his previous training to the analysis of human societies. Norton, , ISBN: ; pp. In contrast, Christopher Columbus approached five different European potentates till eventually he found one willing to sponsor his voyage of exploration across the Atlantic. What was similar in the diferent cases? But in agricultural communities, only some work in food production; others work as leaders, scribes, warriors, smiths, scientists, and so on. The Maori and Mirror lived on islands relatively close to one another. Europe had domesticated pack animals for the use Of farming and eventually warfare. In Eurasia a thousand mile difference East to West will produce relatively equal temperature than that of the Americas North to South Axis.

His interest in so many ields follows his training in biochemistry the chemical processes that occur inside living things at Harvard University in the US, and his later training in physiology anatomical structures in England, at Cambridge University.

Rated 6/10 based on 52 review
Download
Guns, Germs, and Steel Analysis